· The Reckoning · Friday, October 2, 2026 · Jim Whelan Boardwalk Hall — Atlantic City, NJ
Every guesser’s full sealed call, graded song by song — ✓ marks a hit. Most songs called won.
| Guesser | Model | Hit/Called | Hit % | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | house | m2-recency-hotness | 5/19 | 26% |
| 2. | medium | stack-v1-rrf | 3/18 | 17% |
| 3. | crstlbl | m4-gbm | 3/19 | 16% |
| 4. | gpt | gpt:gpt-5.1 | 3/19 | 16% |
| 5. | ai | ai:gpt-5.1 | 1/18 | 6% |
| 6. | local | local:qwen2.5:7b-instruct-q4_0 | 1/19 | 5% |
| 7. | trial | trial:gemini-2.5-pro | 1/19 | 5% |
| 8. | crowd | crowd | 0/12 | 0% |
| 9. | player:PHX-GVJR | human | 0/12 | 0% |
house called — ✓ Tweezer · Character Zero · Harry Hood · Sand · Free · Run Like an Antelope · Possum · ✓ Ghost · Chalk Dust Torture · Carini · What's Going Through Your Mind · No Men In No Man's Land · ✓ A Wave of Hope · Back on the Train · Sigma Oasis · Prince Caspian · ✓ Down with Disease · Tube · ✓ Fuego
medium called — You Enjoy Myself · Also Sprach Zarathustra · Runaway Jim · Everything's Right · Bathtub Gin · Blaze On · David Bowie · ✓ Fuego · Split Open and Melt · ✓ Fluffhead · Golgi Apparatus · Backwards Down the Number Line · Sample in a Jar · ✓ Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. · Taste · Divided Sky · Llama · Twist
crstlbl called — Backwards Down the Number Line · Also Sprach Zarathustra · You Enjoy Myself · Runaway Jim · Everything's Right · ✓ Fuego · ✓ Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. · David Bowie · Blaze On · Bathtub Gin · Taste · Split Open and Melt · ✓ Fluffhead · Divided Sky · Llama · Twist · Golgi Apparatus · First Tube · Sample in a Jar
gpt called — Bathtub Gin · Blaze On · Everything's Right · You Enjoy Myself · Golgi Apparatus · Cavern · Wolfman's Brother · The Moma Dance · No Men In No Man's Land · Ruby Waves · ✓ Fluffhead · Run Like an Antelope · Chalk Dust Torture · Split Open and Melt · ✓ Down with Disease · AC/DC Bag · Reba · ✓ Slave to the Traffic Light · Sample in a Jar
ai called — You Enjoy Myself · Also Sprach Zarathustra · Runaway Jim · Bathtub Gin · David Bowie · Divided Sky · Golgi Apparatus · Llama · The Lizards · AC/DC Bag · Sample in a Jar · Run Like an Antelope · ✓ Say It To Me S.A.N.T.O.S. · Stash · Chalk Dust Torture · Harry Hood · Maze · Sand
local called — ✓ Tweezer · Possum · Sand · Sigma Oasis · Tweezer Reprise · Harry Hood · Free · Character Zero · Back on the Train · Chalk Dust Torture · Run Like an Antelope · Mike's Song · Weekapaug Groove · You Enjoy Myself · My Friend, My Friend · Runaway Jim · Also Sprach Zarathustra · Wolfman's Brother · The Moma Dance
trial called — Also Sprach Zarathustra · Mike's Song · Weekapaug Groove · You Enjoy Myself · David Bowie · Bathtub Gin · ✓ Slave to the Traffic Light · Runaway Jim · AC/DC Bag · Tweezer Reprise · Blaze On · Suzy Greenberg · Cavern · Simple · The Squirming Coil · Stash · Maze · Everything's Right · Reba
crowd called — I Am Hydrogen · Bouncing Around the Room · The Lizards · Farmhouse · Birds of a Feather · Reba · Weekapaug Groove · Bathtub Gin · Also Sprach Zarathustra · Soul Planet · Divided Sky · Mike's Song
player:PHX-GVJR called — Reba · Also Sprach Zarathustra · Bouncing Around the Room · The Lizards · Mike's Song · I Am Hydrogen · Weekapaug Groove · Farmhouse · Soul Planet · Birds of a Feather · Bathtub Gin · Divided Sky
We print every call we made and which ones hit (✓) — our own sealed predictions, never the whole setlist. See the official record → phish.net.
Songs this band had not touched in a long time, coldest first. The tag is how deep into their own back catalogue it reaches.
Coldest of the night: Alumni Blues, gone 158 shows. Gaps count shows, not days — and how cold is "cold" is measured against this band’s own history, so the bar moves with the catalogue. Full setlist → phish.net.